So I have now been using Spotify for about a week after sumarily deserting Rhapsody (no stickyness at all!) Here’s my summary:
Pro Spotify
Has a nice downloadable client on Mac which I can launch from the Dock
I seem to be discovering some new music from non-American Jazz artists. Not sure this is a credit to Spotify or just luck
Neutral
Exactly the same price
Apparently equally large catalogs
Against Spotify
Relies purely on an obscure search syntax (e.g. “genre:”Piano Jazz”) to search genres
Does not have ratings based on genres – i.e. top downloads or new this week in Classical.
Has a confusing relationship with iTunes. Why does it offer me to ‘download’ my iTunes and make it available ‘offline’? iTunes already does this on iPhone
No way to know what ‘genres’ it actually knows about beyond the obvious: “Classical” and so on. Is there “Singer Songwriter”? Is there “New Orleans Jazz”? No idea.
Jury is still out for me…